For years I resisted carrying spinners on Finesse-Fishing.com. When I was younger, my go-to lure was a Mepps spinner. I caught lots of fish with it. I also got enough line twist that I had to respool frequently. When I started Finesse-Fishing.com I concentrated on spoons, which are also extremely effective but do not cause line twist if you fish them correctly. If you get line twist when fishing a spoon you are retrieving it too fast. With a slow retrieve, it will wobble rather than spin. At worst, it will spin one way, wobble a bit, then spin the other way. The alternating directions cancel each other out.
All of the spinners I fished, whether Mepps or Panther Martins or Rooster Tails, caused line twist - enough so that I gave up on spinners. I actually gave up on spinners just about the same time I gave up on treble hooks.
When I got an Aldebaran BFS reel I wanted to see how light a lure I could cast. I took one of my old size 0 Mepps spinners and went fishing. Before long, I caught the fish shown above. It managed to get all three points of the treble hook firmly embedded. It was almost impossible to remove the treble hook and although I finally was able to release the fish, I am not at all confident that it survived.
Nearly all US spinners come with treble hooks. If you look
hard enough, you might find some single hook spinners, but only with
ungainly, large-barbed Siwash hooks. The hooks are not attached with split
rings, so it is hard to replace the factory hook with a single barbless
or micro-barb hook.
Also, spinners are not very popular in Japan. In Areas (private pay-to-fish lakes), micro spoons are much more popular. In streams, sinking minnow lures are much more popular. Concentrating on how Japanese anglers fished, I just didn't import spinners.
Here in the US, though, spinners are popular. much more so than either spoons or minnow lures. Basically, people here want to fish spinners, particularly when fishing for trout in streams. What finally convinced me to import some JDM spinners was an email from an angler I respect, one who is very knowledgeable about JDM fishing gear, who told me of a couple Japanese spinners that do not cause line twist. It turns out they come with single hooks, so I decided to give them a try. I am now a believer.
The spinners I've chosen to carry have a different design philosophy than the spinners that are readily available in the US. All of them come with a built-in swivel to reduce line twist. All of them attach the hook with a split ring, so it is easy to change or replace hooks. Most come with a single hook. The Smith Niakis and AR-S have treble hook models and single hook models. I chose the single hook models. The Daiwa Silver Creek spinners come with a treble hook, but I will include a single hook with each spinner so you can replace the treble if you wish.
They are more expensive than the spinners you can buy in a big box store, but they're better spinners.
Daiwa Silver Creek Spinners
(single hook included with each spinner)
The hooks are sharp.
The coffee's hot.
The fish are slippery when wet.